N.J. Gov: ‘Money Coming Back Our Way’ Key to NYC Toll Deal

Murphy Wants Revenue Talks as Federal Approval Spurs Opposition
Phil Murphy
“Get us to the table,” Murphy told reporters. “We’ll come with good intentions, and if there’s a reasonable deal, we’ll figure it out. And that has not happened.” (Jeenah Moon/Bloomberg News)

[Stay on top of transportation news: Get TTNews in your inbox.]

New Jersey Gov. Phil Murphy said that while he’s committed to trying to block New York City’s congestion pricing plan, he’s open to negotiating a deal that would allocate a portion of the revenue to his state.

“We’re going to try like heck” to stop congestion pricing, he said in an interview with Bloomberg Television on Nov. 22. “I don’t know what the alternative is for the MTA, but I strongly would like to encourage them to pursue other avenues,” he added, referring to New York’s Metropolitan Transportation Authority.

The federal government this week approved a $9 tolling structure for New York City’s plan to charge drivers entering large parts of Manhattan, a key step for the congestion pricing program as it moves toward an anticipated Jan. 5 start date. Trucks would pay more than $14.



Murphy, 67, a former investment banker for Goldman Sachs Group Inc., said he would be willing to discuss a revenue-sharing deal with New York officials.

“Get us to the table,” he told reporters in an earlier interview. “We’ll come with good intentions, and if there’s a reasonable deal, we’ll figure it out. And that has not happened.”

The plan is an attempt to reduce traffic congestion and pollution while raising money for the MTA, which runs the city’s subways, buses and commuter rail lines. Murphy, a Democrat, has been a vocal opponent of the initiative, saying it puts an undue burden on New Jersey commuters who drive into New York for work.

“I don’t know what that deal looks like. But it would have to include money coming back our way. I just don’t see any other way,” he added.

The Federal Highway Administration on Nov. 21 signed off on a revised congestion pricing structure that New York Gov. Kathy Hochul reduced by 40% to help working families and small businesses absorb the new fee, according to documents posted Friday to the MTA website. The FHWA, the state and New York City also signed a value-pricing pilot program agreement for the plan.

“While this policy’s obviously controversial, I hope New Yorkers, whatever their opinion, can recognize that this is a significant moment when we are saying that we can do things to address the big challenges that we as a city and as a region face,” Janno Lieber, the MTA’s chief executive officer, told reporters Friday following the federal approval.

RoadSigns

John Elliott of Load One demonstrates how onboard video combined with AI-enabled analytics can transform fleet safety. Tune in above or by going to RoadSigns.ttnews.com.  

New Jersey sued the federal government last year, claiming it hadn’t done an adequate environmental review of the tolling program. Murphy claims the plan would increase congestion and pollution in his state along routes that avoid the central business district in Manhattan, such as towns near the George Washington Bridge.

His lawyers have urged the judge to rule and said lowering the toll doesn’t resolve the “defects” in the environmental review process.

On Nov. 22, U.S. District Court Judge Leo Gordon, who is overseeing New Jersey’s suit, set an in-person status conference for Nov. 26. It will be the first time the parties will meet before the judge following the federal government’s approval of the $9 tolling plan.

Sri Taylor, Michelle Kaske and Skylar Woodhouse contributed to this report.

Want more news? Listen to today's daily briefing below or go here for more info: